Soft Top vs. Hard Top Roof Tent: Which Is Right for You?
Many people looking to buy or rent a roof tent are torn between a soft-top and a hard-top roof tent . While both seem convenient at first glance, there are clear differences in weight, ease of use, and durability. In this article, we'll explain the advantages and disadvantages of both models step by step, so you'll know exactly which roof tent best suits your car and travel plans.
What is a Soft Top Roof Tent?
A soft-top roof tent is a lightweight version of a roof tent. These tents have a zip-off cover and open like an accordion. They are popular because they:
-
Lightweight ones are often around 30-40kg, making them suitable for almost any car with roof racks.
-
Stay affordable – this is usually the cheapest way to use a roof tent.
-
When folded compactly they are thin and cause less wind noise and fuel consumption.
-
Quickly set up: within a minute you open the tent, slide out the ladder and your bed is ready.
-
Practically delivered with mattress, sturdy ladder and handy storage compartments.
Soft top roof tents are ideal for short trips, weekend getaways and for cars that cannot carry much weight on the roof.
What is a Hard Top Roof Tent?
A hard-top roof tent has a sturdy plastic or aluminum exterior (the hardshell). This provides the tent with better protection while driving and extra durability for intensive use. The key features are:
-
Durable hardshell design withstands rain, wind and dirt on the go.
-
Super-fast opening and closing with gas springs allows the tent to open or close in seconds.
-
Durable and robust, suitable for long journeys and intensive camping holidays.
-
More comfort, often provided with a thicker mattress and extra ventilation openings.
-
Compact and tightly folded aerodynamically, less wind noise and fuel loss.
Hard top roof tents are ideal for travelers who are often on the road, take longer road trips, or are looking for extra comfort in any weather.
Soft Top vs. Hard Top Roof Tent, Advantages & Disadvantages
| Feature | Soft Top Roof Tent | Hard Top Roof Tent |
|---|---|---|
| Weight | Extra light (±30–40 kg), fits almost every car | Heavier (±50–60 kg), often suitable for larger cars |
| Price | Usually cheaper, ideal entry-level model | More expensive, long-term investment |
| To set up | Unfold and extend the ladder within 1 minute | Even faster with gas springs, in seconds |
| Comfort | Basic comfort, standard mattress | Often a more luxurious mattress and better ventilation |
| Sustainability | Sufficient for weekends and holidays | Very robust, resistant to intensive use |
| Collapsed | Ultra-compact, only a few centimeters thick | Compact and aerodynamic, sleek appearance |
| Ideal for | Small cars, short trips, budget travelers | Long journeys, all-round use, comfort seekers |
Which roof tent suits your car and your trip?
The choice between a soft-top and hard-top roof tent depends mainly on your car, travel style, and budget.
-
Small cars or hatchbacks → Choose a soft-top roof tent . Weighing around 33 kg, this model is suitable for almost any car with roof racks. Ideal for short trips or weekend getaways. View our soft-top roof tents. .
-
SUVs and larger cars → Choose a hardtop roof tent . The sturdy hardshell design is ideal for longer road trips and intensive use. Perfect if you travel a lot or camp frequently. Discover our Hardtop Roof Tents .
-
Budget-conscious adventurers → Want to gain experience without investing a lot? Then a soft top is the most affordable choice.
-
Comfort seekers and long journeys → Looking for maximum durability, weather resistance, and comfort? Then a hard-top is more than worth the investment.
Both options provide a comfortable sleeping spot on top of your car, but the right choice depends on your travel plans.
Conclusion
Whether you choose a soft-top or hard-top roof tent , both models make camping easier and more comfortable. A soft-top is lightweight, affordable, and ideal for short trips or small cars. A hard-top is more robust, quicker to open, and suitable for long trips and intensive use.
At DaktentDump.nl you'll find both models at the best prices, always delivered with a mattress, ladder and free assembly in the Netherlands and Belgium.
Discover our Soft Top Roof Tents and Hard Top Roof Tents , or contact us directly for personal advice
0 comments